Thursday, August 19, 2010

Want an Award: Send a Check

If you are a manager and have attended any event using your e-mail address and title you probably found yourself on a SPAM e-mail list. If that be the case I am sure you have been notified of the great honor of being nominated for the Who’s Who of (prestigious name). I remember the first time I received this exciting e-mail: I quickly clicked through to complete my biographical information for the listing, and just as quickly discovered the $50 “listing fee.” Wow, I looked around to make certain nobody saw me click through to what was now obviously a scam. I didn’t want to look foolish.

How many people do you think actually complete that information and pay the $50? I’ll admit, I’ve read of that great honor bestowed on numerous individuals I have seen speaking at events. When I read the notation in their biography I immediately lose a level of respect for the person before I even listen to them speak. Are they so insecure that they think paying $50 for an “award” provides them with credibility?

It isn’t difficult to understand the scam: Send out 1,000 e-mails per day, have 20 managers actually pay the listing fee and you earn a cool $1,000 per day. Over a 240 day business year you earn $240,000 and the required investment to set-up this business? A slick looking website ($2,000), an e-mail distribution account ($200), and a list of managers ($5000). For a small investment of $7,200 these scammers collect $240,000 per year. Maybe they should buy twice as many e-mail addresses!

There have been numerous opportunities in the imaging business to buy an award. Now there is one more—for a mere $900 per month you can be named one of the top 100 service dealers in the country, or is it the world? For those predisposed to taking other’s money without providing tangible value it is a great….shall we say scheme, in that 100 companies paying $900 per month is an astonishing $1,080,000 per year, without doing a stitch of work other then selling these unsuspecting business people on the value of the award. You might even sell some of the “top 100” companies some consulting services: Imagine you get some of those “top 100” to pay you a fee to come in and train their sales force on how to market the recently acquired designation! Cha-Ching.

How could you possibly designate a company as top in anything without reviewing the entire pool of candidates? If you wanted to determine the top 100 universities wouldn’t you need to evaluate all qualified universities against a clearly defined set of criteria? Doesn’t the company certifying the top 100 universities need to be independent? If that certifying company was paid only by the universities that earned a spot on the top 100 list would there be any credibility in the list?

You could be a top 100 service company; you could be a Who’s Who, you could “earn” a degree from an unaccredited diploma mill “university,” but wouldn’t you rather spend your hard earned dollars on some marketing that will truly bring you respect? Over the last 25 years I have witnessed the imaging industry transform from the Wild West into a group of highly professional business operators. There is no need to resurrect the evils of the past with paid for awards.

What I have learned is that some dealerships are thirsting for a reputable industry player to certify that they have a quality customer service organization. Clearly service, including back office operations, is a determinant in selecting a vendor. As the only industry player with experience in all aspects of a dealership operation I take it as a challenge to support this need.

You can bet SD will never take your money with any type of scheme that can pretend to designate you as one of the top 100 organizations in the industry, since it would be impractical to think we can evaluate every dealership (and what if two dealerships in the same market were both stellar…is there any legitimacy in saying one is top 100 because they paid us first when the other might actually be superior) but we certainly have the skill set to know what good looks like. Look for an announcement in the not too distant future on how we’ll quench that thirst with legitimacy.

Wednesday, August 18, 2010

Poll: Managed Print Services – Are you on board?

To keep your finger on the pulse of what your peers are thinking and doing, Strategy Development will be conducting monthly surveys, on hot topics in the imaging industry. Results will be published in our monthly newsletter: sddigest. Not registered for our newsletter? Click here to send me an email with your contact details.

Please take two minutes (literally!) to participate in this poll: Managed Print Services - Are you on board?


sdpulse

Tuesday, August 17, 2010

Introducing ClearView, a tool to properly price and position MPS opportunities

Strategy Development has worked with a leading software developer to translate their knowledge and insight of proper pricing of managed print services (MPS) engagements into a comprehensive Excel-based pricing tool: ClearView. ClearView is user-friendly and easily blends expenditures for mixed fleets, related consumables, and services into a single cost-per-page (CPP). The blended CPP can enable a customer to reduce costs and/or allow print providers to improve margins.

ClearView turns data into intelligence in order to calculate a current CPP, as well as what a blended CPP would be in a variety of potential scenarios. The tool enables comparisons of MPS transactions from simple outsourcing, to redeployment, consolidation or refresh of devices, as well as comparing total cost of ownership to the prospect’s/customer’s current cost. Additionally, ClearView provides the ability to contrast costs from period to period to assist in conducting quarterly account reviews, a process developed by Strategy Development for the MPS space.

ClearView is being made available to Strategy Development’s consulting clients and participants in the BTA MPS Workshops, which were developed and are instructed by Strategy Development consultants. If you are current consulting customer or have attended a BTA MPS Sales or BTA Operations & Service training workshop in the past twelve months, click here to register for the training webinar which will take place on Wednesday, September 1, 2010 at 11am EST/8 PST.

Monday, August 16, 2010

Introducing WebEd: A monthly educational webinar series

This month Strategy Development is launching WebEd, a free educational webinar series to provide monthly training for sales, operations, and service professionals.

The series kicks off with two webinars: In the service track on August 24, Manage a Service P&L — How to Read, Interpret and React and, in the sales track, MPS Assessments – Know when to hold ‘em, know when to fold ‘em on August 25.

Manage a Service P&L — How to Read, Interpret and React
With a precise understanding, the service income statement (P&L) will provide a service manager with the information needed to make sound business decisions and realize 52% plus returns. Comprehension of how managed print services (MPS) business affects the P&L adds a layer of complexity that requires specific knowledge. This level of understanding can only be realized with the proper education of how to interpret, act, and communicate within the organization.

Date: Tuesday, August 24
Time: 11am EST/8am PST
Duration: 45 minutes
Speaker: Mike Woodard
Click Here for More Information and to Register



MPS Assessments… know when to hold ‘em, know when to fold ‘em
The assessment is the step in the sales cycle where you capture the information to justify the financial aspect of the MPS business case. Learn the in’s and out’s of performing assessments; when to walk away from a perceived opportunity; overcomplicating the process; to map or not; about gaining all of the critical information to justify a contract; as well as the perils of not having an champion or an agreement on pain. Avoid the many pitfalls that will help enable you to capture a large recurring revenue stream. Having knowledge of what NOT to do is as important as learning what you need to do well.

Date: Wednesday, August 25
Time: 11am EST/8am PST
Duration: 45 minutes
Speaker: Ed Carroll
Click Here for More Information and to Register




Hope to see you there!

Never Listen to Anybody Worse Off Than You

Words of wisdom I learned from the great sales trainer Tom Hopkins when I attended his three day boot camp in the 1980s. I was in my twenties and new to the outside sales game, but they are words I have lived by throughout my business career, and not simply as a sales professional. The words are so simple and logical, yet have such profound implications.

Would you take medical advice from the guy who failed high school biology and works at the tire store installing your new tires? Would you listen to the doctor who thought you could install your own tires with two crowbars? Would you invest your money with the middle age guy living with his parents who doesn’t have enough capital to make his car payment and is close to filing personal bankruptcy?

At that sales training seminar back in the 80’s those words were profound, yet the meaning was also clear. The three examples I gave above could easily be identified because you would be standing in front of the person and wonder why this guy in the tire store uniform was giving you medical advice.

Now let’s fast forward twenty years. That tire changer, who flunked high school biology, has a blog titled “DeathoftheDoctor” and espouses his opinion on medical issues. He never really says anything with any substance, rather he just attacks anybody else that does and uses pithy phrases to indicate they are fools. Eventually, those “fools” begin to disappear from the blog since they didn’t sign-up to get berated and the only posters left are the real fool, your high school biology failure, and a small group of other flunkies who agree with this unqualified guy giving out medical advice.

The internet, self promotion, and lack of substance have elevated this guy—mostly in his mind because let’s face it he still goes to the tire shop each day—into some type of cult guru.

That 45 year old “investment guru” who attended two different obscure colleges over eight years, yet never graduated, also has his blog, “FailedInvestor.” This guru claims to have invented the hybrid investment approach—a long/short hedge enhanced with options. He claims it is the phase 3 of the modern approach to investing. He has all types of fancy charts and phrases and he too loves to attack others. You hear things like the large investment banks are stuck in the past and don’t understand his strategy and he was first to do this or that, but without much examination you can easily see that he simply changes terms and puts out press releases. His obsession with self promotion—a characteristic of all of these cyber world experts—even attracts some fools to invest in his fund. But in the end all is lost.

The point of this post goes directly back to the words of Tom Hopkins but links those words with the world we live in today. A blog, postings on LinkedIn or Facebook, giving a presentation at a show, or a press release doesn’t make you an expert. Education and experience are what makes an expert. Spend some time to get to know the specific experience of those you seek for advice and you will save a great deal of money and time.

Thursday, August 12, 2010

For U.S. Remanufacturers, MPS Is Both A Blessing And A Curse

by Charles Brewer

It’s increasingly difficult to make money marketing remanufactured toner cartridges in the United States. Remanufacturing cartridges that perform well consistently has always been a challenge and that challenge has been compounded significantly with the introduction of new imaging technology, particularly color. Finding vital supplies has also become an issue. The supply of empty cores--the remanufacturing industry’s life blood--has been drying up for the past few years and the price of empties has skyrocketed. And most importantly, years of fierce competition led by large companies both foreign and domestic has resulted in severe price compression and razor thin margins.

Medium-sized remanufacturers in the U.S. have been hit the hardest. Many mid-sized players were established at a time when they could cover the majority of the market producing only a handful of cartridges. Now, remanufacturers must offer dozens of different SKUs to supply today’s diverse installed base. Many mid-sized firms, however, lack the capacity to produce such a wide array of cartridges. These firms now must outsource the majority--if not all--of their production. This has caused a fundamental shift in the industry, and many companies have changed their business models from that of a producer to a distributor. Outsourcing can be expensive and being profitable while selling cartridges from a third party is a difficult proposition especially when selling monochrome SKUs, which have become increasingly commoditized.

Those mid-sized companies that continue to produce cartridges in-house also find it difficult to turn a profit. Often they lack the economies of scale needed to negotiate lower raw material prices with suppliers so their costs are high compared to the big guys. The smaller firms get little respect from empties brokers and must pay top dollar for the most popular cores--if they can get them at all. Suffice it to say that for those firms that have been able to continue to produce their own products, the overhead has grown to a point where they find it hard to operate profitably.

Managed print services seemed to offer remanufacturers relief from some of their most vexing problems. First and foremost, MPS was seen as a way to add value to commoditized products. Just like it does for hardware vendors, MPS held the promise of improved margins by providing remanufacturers with a way to wrap valuable services around their consumables. It could also give mid-sized firms a vehicle to differentiate themselves as a service provider in the marketplace. Depending on how they shaped their MPS services, remanufacturers could reap added benefits like having some say as to the type of equipment their clients would employ, which would limit the range of SKUs the remanufacturer had to provide. And, it would allow the remanufacturer the ability to collect precious empties--a service that the clients would also value.

The remanufacturing industry as a whole became aware of print management solutions about five years ago. Initially, interest was strong, but remanufacturers recognized they faced a number of hurdles if they were to offer MPS packages. They lacked technology, for example, to monitor their clients’ machines even for the most basic MPS offering. And they had to move from the transactional sale associated with selling cartridges to the solution sale required for an MPS contract. Remanufacturers also faced logistical changes as they moved from providing some fixed number cartridges to supplying customers with cartridges as needed.

As the industry continued to demonstrate a desire to offer MPS, various companies have come forward to support remanufacturers. Technology to monitor printer fleets, for example, has been increasingly available from firms like PrintTracker, PrintFleet, and others. Likewise, various companies have stepped up to help remanufacturers successfully transition from transaction sales to marketing MPS solutions. There are now scores of seminars and workshops aimed at helping smaller remanufacturers launch and manage MPS programs.

Despite all the support and interest, however, it’s not clear that MPS will be the panacea the mid-sized remanufacturers have been looking for. In fact, it’s quite likely they will not be able to offer a profitable managed print service.

It’s difficult for a company that markets supplies exclusively to offer a real managed print program. For clients to realize the full benefits of MPS, there needs to be some degree of fleet optimization, and optimizing a printer fleet requires swapping out hardware. While this may include physically moving devices within an organization and taking some off-line, often it requires deploying new hardware. There are some remanufacturers that are also VARs and they succeed in the MPS market. But those companies that only sell cartridges ultimately will find it impossible to compete with the MPS contracts that dealers and VARs can offer.

Another big challenge that mid-sized firms face are the expenses associated with MPS. It can be costly to acquire the equipment and software required to support monitoring technology. There are companies that will host the services, but outsourcing can get expensive especially for a small company. Remanufacturers also face new cash flow issues. Rather than collecting full payment at or near the time of delivery as they had when they sold cartridges, companies may have to wait months for MPS payments to come in before they can cover their costs. Moreover, often companies must stock up their customers’ supplies closets with inventory and that cache of cartridges may not yield any cash for months.

Some mid-sized firms are learning that rather than offering a new path to profits, MPS really represents new threats. First, large remanufacturers are increasingly active in the space and can undercut the mid-sized players. And, rather than losing one sale, losing an MPS bid means the customer is lost until the contract is up, which is typically between three and five years. Remanufacturers also have to do battle with new competitors as more and more companies offer some type of MPS solution. OEMs are providing new supports to their channel partners, which further strengthen the value proposition of those competing with the remanufacturers.

I don’t want to suggest that MPS is all doom and gloom for remanufacturers. It can open new doors and some new opportunities are emerging. Independent dealers, for example, are increasingly aware of the improved margins remanufactured cartridges can offer them compared to OEM, which is expanding the market for remans. But MPS is not good news for everyone in the industry and it will put further pressure on many remanufacturers doing business in the United States.



With over 12 years of experience, Charles Brewer is an independent consultant for the digital imaging industry. He is a contributing editor to Lyra Research's Hard Copy Supplies Journal published, which he managed from 2005 until 2009. Brewer has authored numerous articles, reports, and white papers on hardware as well as toners, inks, and media and has worked with various OEMS and third-party supplies vendors.

Wednesday, August 11, 2010

The Death of MPS

As the preeminent MPS consulting firm you probably wonder how this title made it onto Strategy Development’s blog. Does Strategy Development really think that MPS will die? The answer to that question is the same as the answer to a few others: Will CPP leasing die? Will digital products die? Will color output devices die? Of course the answer to all of these questions, including the death of MPS, is a resounding “No,” not in the foreseeable future.

So then why “The Death of MPS?” What I do expect to die are individuals (not physically just in discussion), companies, anybody, viewing MPS as some discreet business. I cannot wait to stop getting e-mails touting the latest show on MPS; the latest study on MPS; the latest definition of MPS; the latest MPS sliced bread.

Cost per page, or in the day cost-per-copy, was going to change the business forever; a business model shift and not simply a new approach to leasing. It did change the business in that it built in great switching cost and protected aftermarket. It also had a slight change on the business in the requirement to capture meters and the elimination of large aftermarket sales teams. But it was an evolutionary change and not a revolutionary change. Sure the software providers needed to catch up, but they did, and the dealer/reseller needed to transition their supply reps to meter collectors and supply shippers, and they did, but it wasn’t much of a blip on the screen with the benefit of hindsight.

Then digital was going to forever change the business. Remember the research firms saying, “if you don’t own the network you won’t sell copiers/printers?” A significant business model shift that would leave many copier companies in the dust and out of business: Well that never happened. Digital did have an effect that we are feeling now, printer and copiers go head-to-head, but it was a long change that provided a lot of opportunity to adapt. Owning the network never had an effect on acquiring output devices, and the dealer/reseller developed the skills to sell and maintain digital products and to leverage the professional services that could be sold with, or after, the installation of the device connected to the network.

Then color and production—take your choice: Dealers couldn’t afford to sell and maintain these devices. They were the bailiwick of the OEM with their hordes of cash and ability to deploy sophisticates sales professionals and support teams to support the products. Sorry, wrong again. Dealers adapted and successfully sold color and production, tweaking their business model as they went along.

And now MPS: Some would leave you to believe that MPS was some new and exciting space. I sold my first real MPS agreement in 2002—eight years ago—only we called it fleet management and it was inside of a facilities management (FM) agreement. To be fair our FM team was selling fleet management for years before that, I simply was involved in this transaction because it was a multi-million dollar contract and the customer wanted a full equipment refresh built into the agreement, with the equipment being refreshed over the multi-year agreement. In other words it had Balance Sheet risk so it needed executive engagement. I was also involved in numerous transactions in the enterprise space where the customer wanted to optimize and standardize their output fleet and use professional services, like advanced capture and routing, fax servers, variable data printing, web submission, and document management, to improve their workflow. Today you call these transactions MPS.

For most dealers/resellers MPS is a new go-to-market strategy and it does require changes in the business model, but those changes are becoming a lot clearer today. Early adapters dealt with remote monitoring software that was unpredictable at best. Today’s entrants find software that works well and improves every day. Early adapters worked with leading leasing companies to define contracts; today’s entrants benefit by having contracts that are well written for MPS. Early adapters had vision or faith, or maybe both, that MPS was a real revenue stream where they could make a profit. Today’s entrants have numerous examples of companies in the space growing rapidly and earning nice margins.

The success factors, from a high level perspective, of MPS are also clearly defined: Have a business plan, make an investment in the MPS business, use dedicated sales professionals, use a services led approach, employee quarterly business reviews, be hardware independent, and invest in sales, service and back office operations training. That’s not to say that companies aren’t adapting a MPS strategy at different times or only in portions. You have early and successful adapters, like FlexPrint, and you have many dealers/resellers who say they are in MPS because it is what they feel they need to say, but they really aren’t. The same was true of CPP, color, production, digital, and professional services. I remember Leslie in NYC (acquired by Danka) being the poster child for color back in the day.

We no longer talk about the risk of using a CPP model in our sales approach nor do we view it as a creative marketing approach. We no longer advertise that our products are digital or talk about the analog to digital transformation. We no longer look at production and color devices and wonder if we’ll ever be able to sell and support the devices. Think about this for less than a second: If you didn’t use CPP, didn’t sell digital devices, color, or production what would you be? Not a lot of debate needed as it is an easy answer, basically out of business.

An MPS contract can include imaging and printing devices, support and supply of those devices, software applications related to documents, and consulting services. What does that sound like to you? If you’re reading this blog, and not lost in cyberspace, my guess is it sound like your business? Am I on the mark? So the longer you take to really get into MPS the greater proportion of your customers that will be signing MPS agreements with a competitor. If you competitor is good at MPS it will only be a matter of a few quarters after they get into your account that you are totally displaced. Therefore, MPS becomes both your growth approach and your survival.

This post is really focused on the dealer /reseller. For the OEM MPS can have a significant effect on their business. If all of the dealers / resellers suddenly become hardware agnostic—they simply sell and support what is best for the end users—it could accelerate the winners and the losers in the OEM space. There is also the issue of compatible supplies and InfoTrends has done a good job of quantifying the possible effect on a OEMs revenue stream in this area. The bottom line is that day is coming so the OEMs need to develop a model that makes their products the best choice for deployment inside of an MPS agreement. Maybe we’ll make that the topic of a later post.